elden ring shadow of the erdtree shit design

2 min read 02-10-2024

elden ring shadow of the erdtree shit design

The world of Elden Ring, from FromSoftware, has been celebrated for its breathtaking landscapes, intricate lore, and immersive gameplay. However, as discussions about the upcoming Shadow of the Erdtree DLC surface, some fans are expressing their concerns regarding the game's design choices. In this article, we will explore the criticisms and highlight the aspects that contribute to the ongoing debate about game design in this much-anticipated expansion.

1. Understanding the Design Aesthetic

The Beauty of Elden Ring

Elden Ring has become synonymous with hauntingly beautiful visuals and detailed environments. From the majestic trees of the Lands Between to the grotesque yet fascinating character designs, every element feels like a piece of art. But with the launch of Shadow of the Erdtree, some players are questioning whether the design remains true to the essence of the original game.

Potential Pitfalls

Repetition of Themes: Critics argue that the DLC could fall into the trap of reusing certain design elements, making the experience feel less fresh and more like a rehash of previous content.
Lack of Cohesion: Some fans worry that the thematic coherence that tied the original game together might be compromised in the expansion, leading to disjointed experiences.

2. Design Choices That Spark Debate

2.1. Visual Identity

The visual language in games is crucial, much like how colors set the mood in a painting. Shadow of the Erdtree is expected to continue with the dark and enchanting tones that characterize Elden Ring, but some fans fear that the new areas may not resonate as deeply as the original landscapes.

2.2. Character Design

One of the standout features of Elden Ring was its memorable characters. However, the introduction of new characters in Shadow of the Erdtree has sparked discussions about whether these new designs will match the depth and creativity of their predecessors.

2.3. Gameplay Mechanics

In any game, mechanics are the backbone of player interaction. Players are eager to know if the new gameplay mechanics introduced in the DLC will enhance the experience or clutter the already rich gameplay system.

3. Why Design Matters

Design is the invisible thread that binds a game together. It influences:

Player Immersion: A well-designed environment pulls players into the story, making them feel like part of the world.
Emotional Engagement: Characters designed with thoughtfulness can evoke empathy and investment in their journeys.
Replayability: Innovative and fresh designs can encourage players to explore the game multiple times, discovering new aspects with each playthrough.

4. Finding a Balance

Listening to the Community

Game developers often draw inspiration from the community. Engaging with player feedback can guide design decisions that resonate more with the audience, ensuring that the essence of the game remains intact.

Experimenting vs. Tradition

Creating a compelling game requires a delicate balance between innovation and tradition. New ideas can breathe life into a franchise, but too much change can alienate long-time fans.

Conclusion

While the design discussions surrounding Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree highlight some valid concerns, it's important to approach these debates with an open mind. Design is inherently subjective, much like art itself. The final verdict will ultimately rest with the players once they immerse themselves in the new world. Only time will tell if Shadow of the Erdtree stands up to the legacy of its predecessor or if it wanders into the shadows of design pitfalls.